Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Full Text Issue Listing |
Summary: | COUNTIF with criterium <>number does not count empty cells | ||
---|---|---|---|
Product: | Calc | Reporter: | Regina Henschel <rb.henschel> |
Component: | code | Assignee: | AOO issues mailing list <issues> |
Status: | CONFIRMED --- | QA Contact: | |
Severity: | Normal | ||
Priority: | P3 | CC: | issues, oliver.brinzing, rainerbielefeld_ooo_qa |
Version: | 3.4.0 | ||
Target Milestone: | --- | ||
Hardware: | PC | ||
OS: | Windows, all | ||
See Also: |
https://issues.apache.org/ooo/show_bug.cgi?id=123063 https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=73081 |
||
Issue Type: | DEFECT | Latest Confirmation in: | 4.1.0-dev |
Developer Difficulty: | --- |
Description
Regina Henschel
2013-12-27 19:04:23 UTC
Additional info: (a) I agree, definitively not in accordance with ODF definition (b) Competitors Behavior (b1) Gnumeric 1.10.16: As AOO result = 1 Gnumeric 1.12.9: As AOO result = 1 (b2) OOo 1.1.5. 2.0.2, 3.3.0 As AOO result = 1 (b3) Calligra 4.7.4: As AOO result = 1 (b4) LibO 4.1.3: As AOO result = 1 (b5) SoftMaker FreeOffice: Different to AOO result = 2 (b6) MS Excel 2010: Different to AOO result = 2 (c) Although I see some applications for current behavior (most times nobody is interested in including empty cells), we should follow the ODF definition. Current behavior in Regina's example with correct behavior can be reached with =COUNTIF(B2:B4;"<>7")-COUNTBLANK(B2:B4) (d) Already reproducible with Pre-3.4.0 (OOo 1.1.5), but because of crippled Version selector (Bug 123063) no useful info can be contributed (e) Related to "Bug 98891 - COUNTIF cannot count blank cells"? May be this one is more or less a DUP? (f) Related to "Bug 65221 - SUMIF, COUNTIF, COUNTBLANK, DCOUNT, DSUM, ... with empty cells and "" and ="" empty string criteria"? (g) Related to "Bug 108991 - COUNTIF gives inconsistent counts of empty arrays"? @Regina: What do you think concerning relations? . @Rainer: (a)(b) The specification is unambiguous here. For me it is not the question whether to change the value but when. Changing the result for an existing function is always difficult and a plan for change-over is needed. (c)(d) COUNTBLANK has implementation dependent handling of zero-length strings and should be avoided in environments where interoperability is needed. The concept of a namespace for formulas (especially the namespace "OpenFormula") and the exact definitions of function results for OpenFormula is new in ODF1.2. Therefore older behavior cannot determine the current results. But we need to think about a way to handle old documents. That problem exists in general, not only with function COUNTIF. (e) Bug 98891 was a problem how to write a criterion. It is not relevant here. (f) Bug 65221 is about handling of zero-length strings. Those are not included here. Therefore it is no duplicate. But bug 65221 needs to be re-examined carefully, because in the meantime OpenFormula is specified in ODF1.2. (g) Bug 108991 is about handling of a constant matrix with missing element as part of the search range of COUNTIF. Constant matrices are new in ODF1.2. That is a very special case because of the array formula and should not be mixed with other problems. It is not related to this issue. I remove irrelevant Bugw from "See Also" |