Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Full Text Issue Listing |
Summary: | keyboard friendliness: stop at, move from objects | ||
---|---|---|---|
Product: | Writer | Reporter: | macias <bluedzins> |
Component: | editing | Assignee: | AOO issues mailing list <issues> |
Status: | CONFIRMED --- | QA Contact: | |
Severity: | Trivial | ||
Priority: | P3 | CC: | don.troodon, issues |
Version: | OOo 2.3.1 | ||
Target Milestone: | --- | ||
Hardware: | All | ||
OS: | All | ||
Issue Type: | ENHANCEMENT | Latest Confirmation in: | --- |
Developer Difficulty: | --- |
Description
macias
2008-03-23 10:25:24 UTC
Reassigned to ES. 1) Accessing a formula from the text flow - Shift+F4 - Return 2) Pressing Esc to quit the focus on the object Yes, a formula is not part of the text. It's a object which needs to be edited, entered and leaved, just like a frame or a drawing. Speaking about accessibility, all those elements are accessible. closed Es, I didn't those functions are not accessible at all. The UI is not user-friendly, you are probably healthy person, so you think the issue is solved -- "one million keystrokes less or more, who cares". I care, and handicapped people care -- UI can be much more improved and I don't get it, why it is closed. > 1) Accessing a formula from the text flow > - Shift+F4 It selects the first formula in document, so it is not an answer of this report (reopening). And why not use simply navigation keys, i.e. stop at formula. The formula you stopped at. You know, that in formula editing OOo has strong competitor -- latex, and the more complex editing is the better latex&tools look. It would be easy, intuitive, and requires minimum keystrokes. > 2) Pressing Esc to quit the focus on the object > Yes, a formula is not part of the text. It's a object which needs to be > edited, entered and leaved, just like a frame or a drawing. Ok, then make the focus leave immediately. Again -- why not? What harm is done? Because I can see benefits -- fluent editing (of course I assume we would like to have great OOo, not great theory of editing). Ok, you say it's not user friendly but you don't describe how it would be user friendly. WHat should do the cursor after pressin Right? Select the formula (the object)? Edit it directly? In last case, how to select the formula then? If the formula is edited directly by travelling, the constant opening/closing of the formula command window would also not be user friendly... Please detail... Reassigned to Requirements Es, thank you for the answer, if anything is unclear, please let me know,
maybe I should attach a screenshot.
> WHat should do the cursor after pressin Right?
Ok, a little Ascii notation
| cursor
F formula
*F* formula selected (today, when you LMB on the formula, the green marks
appear)
let's say you have
my grea|t F formula
you press right
my great| F formula
you press right again
my great |F formula
and again!
my great *F* formula
(here is the difference)
...and again
my great F| formula
So -- the navigation is fluent, and there is no penalty comparing to current
behaviour, let's take a look at the situation:
my great *F* formula
you press [enter] and voila you go to the formula editor to edit formula.
<formula>
You press escape and you are back
my great *F* formula
you press, ah, enough of right, -- left
my great |F formula
I hope you see the benefits:
a) intuitive UI, no learning curve at all -- enter, right, left, esc, basic
keys
b) less keystrokes
b.1) handicapped people friendly (comparing to current UI)
c) closer to latex productivity (in math area)
*** Issue 112282 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. *** Yeah, that's a good point. I'll add that after pressing Shift+Right my great |F formula has to become my great [F] formula where [F] is a formula selected like text (not like an object). Another thought is that an ability to jump from formula to formula is also desirable (like Shift+F4 but working in a proper way - one press - one jump, to the next formula). Anyway, I look forward for the progress in this issue too. Speeding up this things is important for creating big texts with formulas. |