Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 121571
Nested recorded/tracked changes do not persist in ODT format, text corruption
Last modified: 2013-02-19 00:58:39 UTC
Created attachment 80093 [details] Test file: nested_tracked_changes.odt When different users edit an ODT file with active change tracking, AOO is supposed to "nest" revisions done by one user inside revisions done by another user when necessary: If User 1 adds text that User 2 later deletes, the insertion revision mark by User 1 is not simply removed but contained inside a deletion revision mark. AOO saves such nested revisions correctly in DOC format, but fails in ODT files: Tracked deletions of tracked insertions are lost after reload of the document, and the deletion text portions are reordered. Test system: AOO 3.4.1 (release) and a newer AOO snapshot (AOO350m1(Build:9611) - Rev. 1420743 / 2012-12-13_04:34:45 - Rev. 1421074), both Linux 64-bit-builds on Ubuntu 12.04/AMD64. Bug is also reproducible in LibreOffice. Reproduce with the attached file: (Keep "Record changes" on. In the following reproduction steps, tracked changes text portions are marked with {}.) Open file "nested_tracked_changes.odt". "Record Changes" is active. User 1 has added the word "big": A mouse is running along the {big} motorway trying to find some cheese. The "Accept or Reject Changes" windows lists 1 tracked change: (1) User 1 insertion of "big" User 2 deletes "running along the big motorway ": The deletion is split into 3 different revision marks: (2) User 2 deletion of "running along the " (3) User 2 deletion of the User 1 insertion "_big_" (4) User 2 deletion of " motorway " A mouse is {running along the }{{big}}{ motorway }trying to find some cheese. Revision (1) is correctly shown as nested inside revision (3) in the "Accept or Reject Changes" window. Save file as "nested_tracked_changes.doc" (WW8) and as "nested_tracked_changes.odt". Close the file. On opening the DOC version, all tracked changes correctly appear as before the file save. On opening the ODT version, the file contents is corrupted: - There are no nested changes: Revision (1) is lost. - The 3 "top level" tracked changes that have survived the ODT save are in incorrect order, that is, the text portions are jumbled: A mouse is {motorway trying }{big }{running along the }to find some cheese.
Created attachment 80162 [details] In build:9593 (details attached) this issue is reproducible. In build:9593 (details attached) this issue is reproducible.
Created attachment 80162 [details] In build:9593 (details attached) this issue is reproducible.