Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 127000
Changing of Measurement units sometimes updates units, but not recalculate amount of Spacing in the field
Last modified: 2017-04-20 07:08:15 UTC
Created attachment 85578 [details] actual result of Step 4 1. Set measurement units to cm ("Tools" => "Options" and then "OpenOffice.org Writer" => "General" => "Settings") 2. Set focus on some txt Paragraph in the document 3. Open Properties slider 4. Set ‘Above paragraph spacing’ variable for this paragraph to 10 cm 5. Change measurement units to inches Actual result: correct, amount is recalculated to 3.94; units are changed from cm to " 6. Change measurement units back to cm Actual result: Units are changed back to cm, but amount is still 3.94 Expected result: Amount should be set back to 10.00
If you try to change Amount by arrow buttons, not-recalculated amount will be decreased/increased, so the paragraph will shifted dramatically and value entered in Step 4 will be lost To see the value recalculated you need to set focus on some other paragraph and come back to this one again
Created attachment 85579 [details] actual result for Step 5
Created attachment 85580 [details] actual result for Step 6
The original bug was replicated using: Hardware/Software: Windows 8 / Apache Open Office 4.1.4 - Windows snapshot build Windows 10 / Apache Open Office 4.1.4 - Windows snapshot build OS X El Capitan version 10.11.6 / Apache Open Office 4.1.3 The follow-up tests were done using Windows 10 / Apache Open Office 4.1.4 - Windows snapshot build Summary: - I was able replicate this bug with the Spacing amount - 10 cm - I was able replicate this bug with different spacing amounts e.g 5 cm, 8.75 cm - I was able replicate this bug for the Indent too - I was able replicate this bug for the different units combination - mm/inch - I was able replicate this bug in case I fill in the Spacing manually and also I use the arrow button - I wasn't able to replicate this bug in Format > Paragraph > Spacing & Indents - I wasn't able to replicate this bug for the Spacing/Indent amounts Please see the detailed test scenarios below: Scenario 1 - replicate the original bug with the 10 cm spacing amount 1. Open a new document in the Open Office Writer 2. Write the text 3. See the Properties slider – the default setting of the measurement units: inch 4. Go to Tools > Options > Open Office Writer > General > Settings and change the measurement units to the cm 5. Go to the first Paragraph 6. Set (fill in manually) the ‘Above paragraph spacing’ to 10 cm in the Properties slider (the spacing was applied correctly) 7. Change the measurement unit setting to: inch (the spacing was recalculated to inch – 3.94'') 8. Change the measurement unit setting to: cm 9. Verify if the spacing was recalculated to cm – the measurement unit was changed but the amount wasn’t recalculated - displayed result is 3.94 cm – please see the screenshot scenario1_result1 10. Verify if the spacing above paragraph was changed as per incorrectly calculated amount - spacing doesn't change - screenshot scenario1_result1 ---------- Scenario 2 - use the different spacing amount 1. Open a new document in the Open Office Writer 2. Write the text 3. See the Properties slider – the default setting of the measurement units: inch 4. Go to Tools > Options > Open Office Writer > General > Settings and change the measurement units to the cm 5. Go to the first Paragraph 6. Set (fill in manually) the ‘Above paragraph spacing’ to 5 cm in the Properties slider (the spacing was applied correctly) 7. Change the measurement unit setting to: inch (the spacing was recalculated to inch – 1.97'') 8. Change the measurement unit setting to: cm 9. Verify if the spacing was recalculated to cm – the measurement unit was changed but the amount wasn’t recalculated - displayed result is 3.94 cm – please see the screenshot scenario2_result1 10. Verify if the spacing above paragraph was changed as per incorrectly calculated amount - spacing doesn't change - screenshot scenario2_result1 Repeat the steps above for the different spacing amounts - 3 cm - the recalculations is correct - screenshot scenario2_result2 - 2.5 cm - the recalculation is correct - but there is the rounding error - scenario2_result3 - 8.75 cm - the recalculation is incorrect - 3.94 cm instead of 8.75 cm - screenshot scenario2_result4 - 9.99 cm - the recalculation is incorrect - 3.94 cm instead of 9.99 cm screenshot scenario2_result5 ------------------------------- Scenario 3 - change another format field - Indent 1. Open the Open Office Writer 2. Create a new document in the Open Office Writer – the default setting of units is inches 3. Go to Tools > Options > Open Office Writer > General > Settings and change the unit settings to cm 4. Go to the first paragraph 5. Set the Before text Indent to 10 cm in the Properties slider (the Indent was applied correctly) 6. Change the measurement unit to inches (the amount was recalculated to 3.94'') 7. Change the unit to cm 8. Verify if the amount of Before indent was recalculated – the amount is recalculated incorrectly 6.73 cm instead of 10 cm - scenario3_result1 Repeat the scenario above for the different Indent amounts - 5 cm - the recalculation is correct - scenario3_result2 - 3 cm - the recalculation is correct - scenario3_result3 - 2.5 cm - the recalculation is correct - but there is the rounding error - 2.49 instead of 2.5 cm - scenario3_result4 - 8.75 cm - the recalculation is incorrect - 6.73 cm instead of 8.75 cm - scenario3_result5 - 9.99 cm - the recalculation is incorrect - 6.73 cm instead of 8.75 cm - scenario4_result5 ----------------------------------- Scenario 4 - use Format > Paragraph > Indents & Spacing 1. Open a new document in the Open Office Writer 2. Write the text 3. See the Properties slider – the default setting of the measurement units: inch 4. Go to Tools > Options > Open Office Writer > General > Settings and change the unit settings to cm 5. Go to the first paragraph 6. Click Format > Paragraph and in the Indents & Spacing tab set the ‘Above paragraph spacing’ to 10 cm (fill in manually) - the spacing was applied 7. Change the measurement unit setting to inches 8. Go to Format > Paragraph and verify if the spacing amount was recalculated and the measurement unit was changed - the amount recalculated to 3.94'' 9. Change the measurement unit setting to cm 10. Go to Format > Paragraph and verify if the amount was recalculated and the unit was changed - the amount was recalculated to 10 cm 11 See the Properties slider and verify if the amount of the Above spacing is recalculated correctly - the Properties slider displays the incorrect amount - 3.94 cm - scenario4_result1 Repeat the scenario above of the Indents - Before text Indent - Before text Indent is recalculated correctly in the Format > Paragraph > Indents & Spacing, the incorrect amount is displayed in the Properties slider - scenario4_result2 ----------------------------- Scenario 5 - use the different measurement unit combination mm/inches 1. Open a new document in the Open Office Writer 2. Write the text 3. See the Properties slider – the default setting of the measurement units: inch 4. Go to Tools > Options > Open Office Writer > General > Settings and change the measurement units to the mm 5. Go to the first Paragraph 6. Set (fill in manually) the ‘Above paragraph spacing’ to 100 mm in the Properties slider (the spacing was applied correctly) 7. Change the measurement unit setting to: inch (the spacing was recalculated to inch – 3.94'') 8. Change the measurement unit setting to: cm 9. Verify if the spacing was recalculated to cm – the measurement unit was changed but the amount wasn’t recalculated - displayed result is 3.94 mm – please see the screenshot scenario5_result1 10. Verify if the spacing above paragraph was changed as per incorrectly calculated amount - spacing doesn't change - screenshot scenario5_result1 ---------- Scenario 6 - use the arrows button for the spacing amount change 1. Open a new document in the Open Office Writer 2. Write the text 3. See the Properties slider – the default setting of the measurement units: inch 4. Go to Tools > Options > Open Office Writer > General > Settings and change the measurement units to the cm 5. Go to the first Paragraph 6. Set (using arrow button) the ‘Above paragraph spacing’ to 10 cm in the Properties slider (the spacing was applied correctly) 7. Change the measurement unit setting to: inch (the spacing was recalculated to inch – 3.94'') 8. Change the measurement unit setting to: cm 9. Verify if the spacing was recalculated to cm – the measurement unit was changed but the amount wasn’t recalculated - displayed result is 3.94 cm – please see the screenshot scenario6_result1 10. Verify if the spacing above paragraph was changed as per incorrectly calculated amount - spacing doesn't change - screenshot scenario6_result1
Created attachment 86011 [details] scenario1_result1
Created attachment 86012 [details] scenario2_result1
Created attachment 86013 [details] scenario2_result2
Created attachment 86014 [details] scenario2_result3
Created attachment 86015 [details] scenario2_result4
Created attachment 86016 [details] scenario2_result5
Created attachment 86017 [details] scenario3_result1
Created attachment 86018 [details] scenario3_result2
Created attachment 86019 [details] scenario3_result3
Created attachment 86020 [details] scenario3_result4
Created attachment 86021 [details] scenario3_result5
Created attachment 86022 [details] scenario4_result1
Created attachment 86023 [details] scenario4_result2
Created attachment 86024 [details] scenario5_result1
Created attachment 86025 [details] scenario6_result1
Created attachment 86026 [details] scenario3_result6
CORRECTION: Scenario 3 - change another format field - Indent - 9.99 cm - the recalculation is incorrect - 6.73 cm instead of 9.99 cm - scenario3_result6
CORRECTION: Summary: I wasn't able to replicate this bug for the Spacing/Indent amounts should be changed to I wasn't able to replicate this bug for all used Spacing/Indent amounts I'm sorry for the typo.