Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 38893
antialiasing missing
Last modified: 2006-03-27 16:50:26 UTC
see attached files. visio object is imported, but it looks slightly different than in msoffice. (i'll file one issue on all differences - have no idea how related are they) 1. visio_object.doc -> visio_word.png and visio_writer.png a) different background colour - which one (word or writer) did get it right ? : ) b) all rounded objects are drawn with straight lines - see arrows and rounded corners of some textboxes; c) arrow colour differs; d) at least for me writer somehow loses file location upon opening - it shows no location in file->properties, title is shown as untitled1 (and opening the document again it's untitled2 etc). if this could not be reproduced, i'll try to test different scenarios. oo.org 1.1.3 has all the text garbled etc, but it get's rounded objects correctly. 2. visio_object.xls -> visio_excel.png and visio_calc.png a) arrow colour differs; b) see horizontal arrow (~ at position c18) - it's positioned and sized slightly differently in calc than in excel. calc has those rounded objects imported & displayed correctly.
Created attachment 20463 [details] word testcase
Created attachment 20464 [details] excel testcase
Created attachment 20465 [details] calc screenshot
Created attachment 20466 [details] excel screenshot
Created attachment 20467 [details] word screenshot
Created attachment 20468 [details] writer screenshot
Confirming with m65
TM->MRU: Please have a look.
The "background color" you can see in Word is not a real background. Word displays all OLE objects like this, to distinguish them from normal graphics. In Word's print, preview it will nor be visible anymore (and also not printed). (Un-)slanted arrow sybols is a bug. The arrow color looks quite equal to me... the "untitled" eror in title bar has already been fixed in 680m71.
MRU->SJ: there should be slanted corners on the arrow objects in the metafile. BTW: can you see any difference in color of the objects? Maybe I'm color blind, I cannot...
ouch. i used msoffice on another computer. it had a crt monitor (old one), linux machine had an lcd. at that crt arrows seemed to be almost yellow. sorry about that :)
sj->thb: The only difference to msoffice is missing antialiasing. Therefore youe are already having a feature request I think. So this issue is most probably double to another bug. I set the Issue type to feature and the target to OOo later, since this feature will not make it into OOo2.0. I also changed the title to better identify this issue.
antialiasing is responsible for these rounded corners & arrows ? and why are they displayed the same as in msword in 1.1.3 ?
->THB: I just noticed there is Issue 28526 which is on user "requirements" and has no target and 75 votes! Maybe you should consider to set this one to duplicate of the other issue (because of the votes) and adapt the target. BTW., a target "OOo 3.0" would look better than "OOo Later" ;-)
@bm: this is not only about antialiasing (it seems there are also some bezier curves missing).
i checked all problems i had listed myself and it seems that they are resolved (at least in m158 :) ) rounded shapes are rounded as they need to be. objects are slightly differently aligned in excel screenshot than they are in calc (still true in m158). but i am not sure wether this can be considered a problem
Excellent. Then, indeed, this one is duplicate. *** This issue has been marked as a duplicate of 28526 ***
And closing.