Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 51708
Inconsistent shadow depending on text color
Last modified: 2013-08-07 14:38:26 UTC
When giving shadows to text, only text that is black has a grey shadow. Any other color and the shadow turns black.
Created attachment 27781 [details] sample text with shadows
MRU->HDU: we should change the shadow color to "grey" for all txt colors (and not just for black color). Other Word processors also use this, so we should keep compatibility.
HDU->CJ: since at least SO5 and probably even earlier the shadow color was either COL_LIGHTGRAY or COL_BLACK, depending on the luminance of the original text. The change request to always use COL_LIGHTGRAY has its merits though, and the rationale behind the original design is no longer obvious this should be decided finally. See issue 759 for some insights of the original designer.
Additional info: As mentioned in issue 759 shadow compatibility with PPT was a concern. Since the new presentation engine is now handled in the Canvas instead of directly in VCL doing something different for VCL is now possible. So the decision on which shadow color to use could distinguish between the use cases Impress/Non-Impress.