Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 5420
batch jpegs to slides
Last modified: 2003-10-20 16:55:53 UTC
being able to covert a folder of jpegs to slides would convert many academic users from powerpoint. Mac programs that do this are common, not pc.
Reassigned to Wolfram.
Changed to new.
Reassigned to Falko.
I guess there are more than one program that does slideshows for JPEGs better than any presentation program.
closed
I think you are missing the point, I strongly disagree that the existance of other programs is reason enough to close this bug report. Being able to quickly and easily generate a slideshow based on a set of images would be a useful feature for OpenOffice to have (I'm not concerned about the image type by the way). If you are in this circumstance (and it is my belief that many users are) and you want to create a slideshow in OpenOffice format it is incredibly tedious to try and create them one by one. Does the OpenOffice project really allow the same person to Resovle and Close a bug report? The other projects I have seen always insist on different users so that there is some necessary oversight. I really think this is a worthwhile feature, Wolfram was willing to accept it as new, so I'd really like a second opinion before accepting this bug as completely closed.
Ok, my comment might haven been a bit short, sorry about this :o( If you want to export your presentation to JPEG please use the HTML-export feature. Here you will get your JPEG's _plus_ HTML pages that embed those JPEGs. FYI, for feature issues we agreed that one person can reject _and_ close an issue. AFAIK this is not possible for reported bugs though. And that Wolfram accepted this issue means in this case nothing else that this issue is a valid feature request but does not contain any validation or evaluation in this case!
> If you want to export your presentation to JPEG please use the It is really very difficult to take you seriously or believe that you understand what we are asking when you say things like that. Export has no relevance to what we are requesting. We have both stated that we want to _create_ new slides from a collection of images (not even JPEGs necessarily) quickly and easily. We want to be able to select multiple images and insert one per page to quickly create a slideshow. I can understand that this might be an extremely low priority, however I cannot understand that it is not a worthwile feature worth implementing in due course. Mark Fox stated offlist that this feature is available in Apple Keynote, hopefully he will repeat his comments here as I have already asked him to do. I am quite familiar with the export facilities of the slideshow program. Offlist Mark Fox expressed his continued interest in this functionality and I still being able to quickly and easily generate a slideshow like this is a killer feature. Other programs doing this "better than any presentation program" merely suggests that we need a better presentation programa and that this is not just an enhancement but a honking great big flaw. I would really appreciate if you would not close this bug again without more substantial reasons. I would appreciate if you could get a second opinion and third opinion for Closing and Verifying this request that seems to have been misunderstood. I would suggest tweaking the title to something like: "batch convert images to slides, one image per slide"
I submitted this suggestion originally.Maybe it would help if I explained its utility carefully.I (and many of my colleagues) often make large presentations that are 50-75% images and the rest text slides. We add each image one at a time with Powerpoint. It would be a huge time savings to dump the image folder into the program and then only have to make the text slides.Interestingly, this feature was added to Keynote by Apple. Thanks to all of you that work on OpenOffice.I am grateful for a Microsoft alternative. Mark
Sorry, I mixed this issue up with another one... I think this happens if one works on too many issues in too little time :o( Again, sorry about that. Nevertheless: We have about 2000(!) open issues that are flagged "Enhancement" or "Feature" plus another 1000 or so that are already evaluated and we really have to draw a line somewhere. Due to a given timeline and an existing roadmap most of these issues will/did not make it into 2.0 anyway anymore. So the bulk goes for "Office later". There again we have to determine what might be important to implement and what is less important. The less important stuff therefore will be turned down and closed. Now let me explain why I do turn down and close this issue finally: 1. It does not fit in our (very tight) roadmap for 2.0 2. It is (as already stated) a very low priotised feature 3. In most cases poeple use the _same_ background for their presentations (or 2 or 3 different ones) 4. This issue has no vote 5. OO.o is an OpenSource project so everyone can feel free to modify and add the product to her/his tastes. If such function is really needed by a very few people it is legitimate to ask those folks to create their own project and eventually distribute their code. And exactly that's what I will do now.
Closed