Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 7311
Hyperlinks can not be removed easily
Last modified: 2013-08-07 14:43:11 UTC
Open the Writer. Type in some text like this: This url http://openoffice.org/ works fine. The url portion will automatically construct a hyperlink out of "/openoffice.org" and make it a "file:" type url - actually I don't hink it should, but that's another story. Ok, select all the text that has a hyperlink, then click either Edit/Hyperlink or Insert/Hyperlink to get the hyperlink dialog. So far so good, the hyperlink will be shown and you can change it if you like. But, how in heck do you remove the hyperlink? I can't see a way to do this. I tried "blanking-out" the existing hyperlink then clicking Apply, but that doesn't work, the link remains.
Never mind, I figured out how to do it (RTFM). But, still-n-all, the user interface isn't terribly intuitive in terms of what I wanted to do. I shouldn't have to go to a completely different menu to undo the affects of adding a hyperlink. It should be possible to both add and remove a hyperlink in the same dialog. Just my opinion anyway.
Russell, thanks for posting your experience. I've changed your issue to an enhancement request.
I've seen this comment crop up before. Maybe there is a way to make the interface more intuitive.
Reassigned to Chtisrian.
When right clicking on the mouse, in the menu should appear the entries "Edit hyperlink" and "Remove hyperlink", but only when the cursor is within the limits of a hyperlink. There is no point in showing these options if there is no hyperlink at the cursor. That solution should be relatively easy to implement, would allow the removal of a hyperlink while not affecting the format and would be very intuitive to the user. By selecting "Remove hyperlink", the link is just gone. One can argue if there should be a dialog to confirm the intention with the user. I leave the debat to you. And of course, "Edit hyperlink" whould pop up the hyperlink dialog.
Reassiged to Bettina.
*** Issue 9479 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
Made subject more meaningful. I repeat parts of my comment from issue 9479 why this is a defect: I agree, removing a hyperlink actually is not a "natural" way. Additionally, no one will understand why it is impossible to remove a hyperlink from some text by using the hyperlink dialog, as I tied: 1. mark text with hyperlink 2. click OOo-button "Hyperlink dialogue" 3. delete hyperlink target 4. "Apply" and OK Expected: Hyperlink will be removed from Text Actual: not removed Same with rightclick "Characters": 11. mark text with hyperlink 12. rightclick, "Characters", card "Hyperlink" 13. delete hyperlink URL 14. "Apply" and OK Expected: Hyperlink will be removed from Text Actual: as expected It is a DEFECT if it is not possible to delete a hyperlink in the special hyperlink dialog (see steps 1. to 4.), so --> DEFECT Rainer
*** Issue 10468 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
*** Issue 10508 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
How to remove a hyperlink is frequently asked question among Danish OOo users. The reply is often to change format to default (see e.g. http://www.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=10508) , but this also changes formatting besides the hyperlink. Since this issue is now the master issue regarding removal of hyperlinks I will add the following. You can open the hyperlink directly from the context menu, but I strongly support adding "Remove hyperlink" and "Edit hyperlink" to the contextmenu also. I find the steps 11-14 (See previous comment) too cumbersome to be the only way to do it. Furthermore, you have to mark the hyperlink in order to bring up "open hyperlink" in the context menu. If you just right click a hyperlink "open hyperlink" will not appear. (Maybe this is connected to another issue.) Finally, I encourage the owner to set OS to All and Version to 1.1 and set it to P3 since part of this issue is actually a defect (See previous post).
Ok it's true, I think not being able to easily remove hyperlinks is a DEFECT for a web-editor. So I change priority with the hope someone sees it and tells us if this will be solved, it's very uncomfortable to work with this problem. It's the only thing that still prevents me to recommend OpenOffice.org to EVERYBODY including those of my friends who like making web pages... :(
set target to something more meaningful :) mh->bh: please set appropiate target.
Hello Andreas, I consider this behaviour as a bug and not enhancement. Thus I reset this issue to you.
Because of limited resources it is not possible to fix this problem for OOo1.1.2. We decided to set this task to OOo2.0.
As discussed, it should be more intuitive to remove a hyperlink.
.
This will not be implemented for OOo 2.0 -> target changed. os->cj: I think I need a spec how it should work.
It was very good if the ability to remove (convert to simple text) many hyperlinks (at once) which are spread all over the document appear. The menu items like "Remove hyperlinks within selected text" or "Convert hyperlinks to text" should be created in "edit" or right click menu.
*** Issue 37066 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
This issue still exists as of OOo 1.9.79 (viz. 2.0 Beta). Steps to reproduce: 1. Type in a URL, for instance http://google.com/ 2. Hit space or enter. 3. Highlight the URL. 4. Open the hyperlink dialogue. 5. Note lack of "clear" button or the like. Additionally, the strategy of resetting to default no longer can be easily found in the documentation. Search for "hyperlink". (Using Windows XP + 1.9.79)
C'mon guys and girls, this feature must be added soon. It is a major usability bummer and this issue is 3 years old!!! On oooforum.org and oooforum.dk we get the question "how do I remove hyperlinks" again and again. When right clicking a hyperlink an edit option should be available, and from the edit hyperlink screen a remove hyperlink button would be great. Since hyperlinks are inserted by autocorrect automatically, this is a major usability issue. The person resposible for delaying a fix for this issue should answer all the !how do I remove the hyperlink" questions at oooforum.org and oooforum.org without copy/paste of the answer! :) Pleeeeease, fix fix!
Another one bytes the dust. Doh! It took me an hour to realize that there is no way to remove hyperlinks without loosing all other formats (font, size, ...) at the same time. This really sucks! Well obviously nobody is in the mood to fix this bug. But I don't want to nag the OOo team -- they do a very goo job --, instead I will offer my help and contribute my mite. So please give me a hint: tell me where to change the source code and I will try to fix it.
*** Issue 23749 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
*** Issue 31850 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
A similiar question has been asked on Polish forums recently. To be honest, sometimes I, too, look instinctively for this option in the context menu, although I use OpenOffice.org for everything. Two additional entries would be just fine. Have a nice day! Konrad
OS implied that a lack of specification for how the remove hyperlink should be implemented is a major reason why this issue will not be addressed until later. I've created a couple of mock ups that can be used as a starting point for discussion. I'm using OO v2.0.1 for Windows, for my examples. First, a screen shot of the present hyperlink dialog box: http://www.skunkwks.com/web/hidden/OOo/hyperlink_dialog_box_current.png Second, a "photoshopped" screen shot of the same dialog box with my proposal for a control to remove the hyperlink: http://www.skunkwks.com/web/hidden/OOo/hyperlink_dialog_box_proposed.png Deragon mentioned the right-click context menu--there is no way to get to the hyperlink dialog box via the context menu. I feel this is an oversight and suggest the following UI modifications. A screen shot of the present right-click context menu. Note, this is of a test document where I entered some URL-like text strings; OO "auto-corrected" some of these to add hyperlinks to them: http://www.skunkwks.com/web/hidden/OOo/rightclick_menu_current.png My proposal for a new right-click context menu: http://www.skunkwks.com/web/hidden/OOo/rightclick_menu_proposed.png Deragon did not suggest it, but I removed "Open Hyperlink". Every entry on the context menu modifies the document _except_ "Open Hyperlink", and left-clicking on the hyperlink opens the hyperlink, a far more preferable user action. As more is not always better, I suggest removal of the "Open Hyperlink" menu item. Additionally, there's a facility to modify hyperlinks within the Character dialog box. A hyperlink is a different beast than any of the other character modifications. Additionally, a hyperlink does not necessarily change the appearance of the character string (nor does it need to even contain a character string as a visual element). In an ideal world, hyperlink editing should _not_ be a part of the Character dialog box.
I hope cj consider the suggestions. Thanks
This bug is from 2002, it is now 2007 and OOo 2.1 is out. It's a pretty bad usability bug. I searched Help and didn't find the answer to how to remove the hyperlink (I searched "URL"). There's mention of the Hyperlink dialog and how to modify its properties, but not removing it. The current method is extremely non-intuitive, and I only found it through this thread. I second what has been said about a simple Remove button and option in the Contextual menu, the first places you look. When you have a Hyperlink dialog, you naturally assume everything you need to add AND remove links are there. A simple button can't be that hard to implement, surely. Nor an option in a Contextual menu. Even with stretched resources.
geez, pretty soon we'll need a 5th anniversary party! :-)
msandersen is right, it's been far too long with no action. While OO Writer isn't exactly broken, if you don't know the trick it can be very frustrating to deal with this. This is the kind of junk that can kill a company's transition from MS Office to Open Office. It only takes a few early adopters in an office to stumble across this, or something similar, and kill any enthusiasm for switching.
I _strongly_ approve the propositions of scottydm from the 31 Jan 07 (all of em: a 'delete hl" button in hl editing box, a remove and edit hl in context menu, _as well as_ NO open hyperlink in this same menu). I think this "bug/defect" is even worse than what some here say: it's not only bad for web editors, as when you make a carriage return after an e-mail adress for example, it DOES TRANSFORM the line to an hyperlink... So what? OOo creates hyperlink when we don't relly want it, and *damn* doesn't even lets us erase them easily? That's a huge problem, really, I'm IT operator, I know somewhat about computers, have a good feeling about using them and all, but when I go in the hyperlink editing tab, _delete_ the hyperlink line and confirm, I just expect the hyperlink to ***** disapear. Won't you? I must also say I love OOo, and am very grateful to you guys who do that work, but this bug is bad. Really. That must be said :)
"I _strongly_ approve the propositions of scottydm from the 31 Jan 07 (all of em: a 'delete hl" button in hl editing box, a remove and edit hl in context menu, _as well as_ NO open hyperlink in this same menu)." I agree wholeheartedly!
*** Issue 83954 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
*** Issue 85211 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
*** Issue 89861 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
Would it make sense to have a "Remove formatting..." option, that would open a window listing the types of formatting that have been applied, and offers something like Formating [X] Hyperlink [ ] Bold [&Cancel] [Remove &All] [Remove &Selected] In this way it would be more general, and help apply to other formatting cases.
Hi Simos, >Would it make sense to have a "Remove formatting..." option, that would open a >window listing the types of formatting that have been applied, and offers >something like ... >In this way it would be more general, and help apply to other formatting cases. per se a good idea to generalize the issue but 1) from a usability point of view, I would not look in "remove formatting" if I wanted to remove a hyperlink. I do not perceive hyperlinks as specially formatted text but as text which I can click to get somewhere else. Maybe one could name it "Remove formatting and links"... 2) how do I edit the link target if I only have the option to remove the link? --> I agree with deragon, when right-clicking on the link I expected two (additional) options, Edit Hyperlink and Remove Hyperlink
I can confirm that this is still an issue in V3 300m8. "when right-clicking on the link [or more importantly selecting a part of a link)such as a '.' at the end] I expected two (additional) options, Edit Hyperlink and Remove Hyperlink" [remove is more important here as edit can be done from the tool bar] It would be good to have this raised and resolved - its a key feature we are missing.
In 3.1 we will have "remove hyperlink" in the context menu of hyperlinks. I will check if we can also implement a simple control in the hyperlink dialog, e.g. as specified by scottydm. Oliver, what do you think: can we also do something like this here: http://www.skunkwks.com/web/hidden/OOo/hyperlink_dialog_box_proposed.png
The entries "Remove Hyperlink" and "Edit Hyperlink" have been added in cws os121 in sw/inc/cmdid.h sw/sdi/_textsh.sdi sw/sdi/swriter.sdi sw/source/ui/inc/swmn_tmpl.hrc sw/source/ui/shells/textsh1.cxx officecfg/registry/data/org/openoffice/Office/UI/WriterCommands.xcu I'm going to open issue 9479 about adding a remove hyperlink function to the hyperlink dialog.
There are two points here: 1) remove hyperlink in the hyperlink dialog (for editing the link). and 2) the option to 'remove a hyperlink' from the right click menu, once a link has been selected. I feel that this is still an issue, but is a nice to have, not a show stopper. Therefore I would like to suggest that the issue is re-opened, but perhaps two separate issues need to be created.
We have the best solution (context menu) done and want to get it integrated. We don't want to wait until we might have fixed the hyperlink dialog. I adjusted the summary to reflect that. IMHO the context menu should be enough, the dialog enhancement indeed would be only "nice to have". So if someone thinks that we need this, please create a new issue.
Issue 9479 _is_ the hyperlink dialog issue.
Sorry, I got confused by the last comment from davidclayton. :-)
The hyperlink dialog issue is Issue 22133.
please verify -> close
->mechtilde: You're a bit too fast. This issue has just been fixed and the cws is not even in QA. Removing needmoreinfo, oooqa and whiteboard status.
*** Issue 22133 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
I found no info about the planned CWS. So I ask now http://qa.openoffice.org/issuelinks.html. so it is easier not to lose the track
Reassigned for verification
ES, please have a look in OS121. Thanks!
1) Not a defect but a feature. Changed Type accordingly. And a feature introducing UI changes ("Edit Hyperlink", "Remove Hyperlink" in the context menu). So, expecting a spec... 2) "Tools - Customize - Keyboard/Toolbars - Category: Edit" has now 2 times "Hyperlink". One is "(Edit )Hyperlink", the other "(Remove )Hyperlink". -> the 2nd one should be called "Remove Hyperlink" though the customize list only shows a terminology with "Delete <object>" (could have been UX prooved...) 3) When selecting a string "www.anysitehere.com" NOT formatted as hyperlink, the context menu shows "Remove Hyperlink" anyway. -> Bug @OS/MBA: Now what do we do? Proposals: a) strict way: CWS back to NEW until Spec is there and everything is fixed b) cool way: @OS: make a Spec ASAP and you'll fix 2) and 3) in an upcoming CWS. I advocate for b) 'cos I'm a cool team player ;)
Spec created ->es: I prefer a) but I cannot reproduce your number 3). Please add a sample document. reassigned to me
Changing from ENHANCEMENT to FEATURE.
->es: Now an additional copy-to-clipboard function has been added and the mentioned problems are solved.
Changed summary
Updates: - Test case specification will be available soon as http://qa.openoffice.org/ooQAReloaded/TestcaseSpecifications/OpenOffice.org_3.0/Word_Processor/Hyperlink_Context_Menu.html - Spec needs an update.
@FHA: please update (new) test cases in the CWS using the new "Hyperlink Context Menu" TCS. For now only available internally.
Verified in CWS os121. All bug fixed. Submitted issue 96810 for frames and pictures.
Verified in DEV300_m39 using .deb version and following TCS - closing - Sophie
*** Issue 103099 has been marked as a duplicate of this issue. ***
Pls see Issue 22133!