Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 77260
Absolute addressing considered harmful
Last modified: 2013-08-07 15:45:17 UTC
I regret that I don't seem to have a visible "attach"ment" button, so the carefully cut down example does not appear here at this time. The use case is as follows. Given an existingg spreaddsheet with fairly elaborrate costing calculations, a writer document was constructed for a related family of proposals. Then the "new database" button was selected, I choose "existing database" type spreadsheet and then dragged the appropriate fields to the right spots in the writer document. This was on a Macintosh running NeoOffice 2.1 patch3, but I replicated the results with OpenOffice 2..1 as well. All was right with the world. However, iI work in a distributed group. So prior to "releasing" this lashup upon my group, I transferred the files over to a Solaris x86 sysetem (running SXDE, not that it seems to matter much) and StarOffice 8 update 5). On the solaris side, the database needed registration (hence the title, aboluute paths considered harmful, relative pathing would have been far handier) after registration, StarOffice8 PU5 *crashes* upon any and all attempts to work witth the database file. Hence I have labeled this a defect. I also moved the files to a Ubuntu 6.10 system which has OOO 2.0.4 i installed. While it doesn't crash, just registering the database fails to provide any useful value, as any attempt to access the database fails silently. I think there are two issues here: 1) Due to the lack of relative addressing, absolute adddresses are put into the database definition. This is unhelpful. I defer to the maintainers judgement whether that should be a separate RFE (I will happily enter itt if so desired). 2) Given that the absolute paths don't exist on the "client" systemss it would appear that there is both a lack of appropriate error checking /handling and a missing facility to fix "incorrect" paths. since this results in crashing on at least one platform, I think it is safe to call this a defect. As the issues are very tightly connected, I have filed them togehther.
Created attachment 45060 [details] sample files, created on the mac that crash on solaris
This is known as re(quest for enhancement) issue 41897 *** This issue has been marked as a duplicate of 41897 ***
closing duplicate
While the RFE component is fairly dealt with as a duplicate, the crashing on the Solaris x64 version of the suite seems to be a defect to me. As the attachment button was in the next pane after my initial comment submittal there is already the sample file(s) online.
Okay, I didn't read the part for the crash carefully enough. Probably http://qa.openoffice.org/issue_handling/basic_rules.html#one_per_issue made me assume that once I spotted the request in this issue, I needn't to look for more :) Could you please adjust OS, Platform, and Summary so that the issue describes the crash then?
To be precise about version, StarOffice 8 Patch Update 5. I'm slightly in the weeds about the precise correspondence of OpenOffice and StarOffice versions (is this 2.1 or 2.2?)
2.1 is correct, AFAIK. Thanks.
Can somebody from Sun Microsystems verify this Solaris-specific issue?
khbkhb, please provide step by step instruction on how to reproduce the crash. Thanks a lot.
overdated issue, no respond, no repro -> set to 'invalid'
=> close please reopen if still occure in a current version thx