Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 87113
ctrl-shift-u for german underline conflicts with gnome unicode input
Last modified: 2009-03-31 15:36:30 UTC
The hotkey for underline in the German localization is ctrl-shift-u which conflicts with the Gnome unicode input method which uses ctrl-shift-u also.
TM->SBA: please have a look, thanks !
I should note that this will affect any locale that uses ctrl-shift-u, not just the german one. The german localization was the one I received the Ubuntu bug report about though. I don't know what other locales use the same hotkey.
wontfix. Means: OOo will not change default shortcuts because of this. Alternatives: Don't use GTK-input method (then you won't be able to use the <ctrl>+<shift>+u method though) Reconfigure the shortcut for underline in OOo via Tools|Configure → Keyboard changing OOo defaults would break consistency with bold and italic shortcuts and consistency with other operating systems. You will never be able to have shortcuts that don't conflict with the defaults of your Desktop-Environment.
closing issue. If you really think that the shortcut should be changed, then bring this to the ux list (with a list of well-founded pros and cons)
"You will never be able to have shortcuts that don't conflict with the defaults of your Desktop-Environment." That is proof that the defaults are brain-damaged and should not be what they currently are. Perhaps the idea of uniform shortcuts across all system types is not feasible at all. Do the shortcuts not work properly on Windows either... or are you basically saying "we found what works on Windows so who cares about anything else" including Gnome which is the defacto Desktop for Linux and most *nix for that matter.
No. I'm not saying that. Reopening this issue will not help. Feel free to patch your distro's version, feel free to take this to the appropriate mailinglist. Until then: Live with it. Wontfix. The comment is proof that no matter what shorcuts you choose, there will always be one that are already used by some other tool. There's nothing to be done about it. And yes, there might be a free combo, but sacrifying consistency (i.e. using "ctrl+shift+k" for underline instead) for that is no option. Take it to the mailinglist, with some well-grounded arguments or live with the conflict/change it locally. You should use styles instead of hard formatting anyway. Leaving this issue open won't help. It will sit there forever, without any change. So wontfix is what it is: Will not be fixed. A honest answer, whether you like it or not. To have a chance to change the shortcuts I can only repeat myself: Bring it to the mailinglists with some good argumentation. Otherwise you're wasting your time.
"take it like a man"... closing.