Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 96465
spellcheck UI fails to warn about language mismatch
Last modified: 2013-08-07 14:38:26 UTC
When a document (or some characters) are marked as one language, while the spellchecker's dictionaries do not include that language, the spellchecker runs, but reports zero errors. This is "correct" operation (obviously don't want French checked against and English dictionary), however as evidenced by numerous bug reports and forum queries, it continues to annoy users. What is missing is some feedback that some words, perhaps all of them have not been checked because there is no appropriate dictionary installed. Also, who knows what language an imported document appears to be. To the average user, the document is in "English" and they have an "English" dictionary installed, so they expect it to work in some fashion. For instance, as I am in New Zealand, it seems sensible to set the default language to "English (New Zealand)". However there is no specific NZ dictionary, so the best I can do is install the Australian or GB dictionaries. Spell check quite happily reports "The spelling check is complete", with no errors reported. I think it should also say "500 words not checked because no English (New Zealand) dictionary is installed" Help text for this message would include info about installing additional dictionaries, and how to change the language of an existing document (select all, format/character:language). An additional feature would be the ability to tell the spellchecker to use a particular dictionary for another 'language' (In my case I'd like some way to say "Use English (Australia) dictionary for English (New Zealand) text" BTW I'm calling this issue a DEFECT because I consider it a UI defect that the checker gives the appearance of working when in fact it is ignoring some or all of the text.
Examples of users problems, I expect there are more... http://www.oooforum.org/forum/viewtopic.phtml?t=27622 http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=95171 http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=47108
You may call it a defect but it needs to be treated as and enhancement because we have to design warnings and solve other questions (should we also mark with AutoSpellCheck as "unchecked" text without installed languages?) Thus, reassigning. Reassigned to Requirements
BTW: for issue reports, please use a current (3.0) version. 2.4.0 is too old.