Bug 27473 - form-editor usability enhancement proposition
Summary: form-editor usability enhancement proposition
Status: NEW
Alias: None
Product: Lenya
Classification: Unclassified
Component: Miscellaneous (show other bugs)
Version: 1.2
Hardware: Other other
: P3 enhancement
Target Milestone: 2.0.1
Assignee: Lenya Developers
URL:
Keywords:
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2004-03-05 14:18 UTC by mathias jud
Modified: 2007-07-16 02:16 UTC (History)
1 user (show)



Attachments

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
Description mathias jud 2004-03-05 14:18:54 UTC
Problems:
a) 
On long and element-rich sites, it is almost impossible 
to maintain the overview in the editor. Everything looks 
the same.
b) 
All Elements that actually can not be edited in the 
Form-Editor, are not shown there too.
c) 
After the creation of a new element, the elements need 
to be searched and selected again to edit it.
d) 
All user-interface-elements are located on the left, 
except "Save" & "Cancel". If an error occurs the 
buttons are often out of view... scrolling to the right 
border of the page...

Solutions:
a)
- The elements should be formated by default as 
(Titel, Headlines ...)
- The left border of a screen is a very important 
place for user-orientation. In the form-editor this 
place is used for the always same-looking 
delete-/edit-buttons. I recommend to show first the 
more significant name of the element.
- "valing" the content of a tag "top" as the name of an 
element, to enhance the ease and the speed of 
comparing element-names with its content.

b)
- These non shown elements (Images / Assets ...) are very
important for the orientation.
- All content-elements should be shown relative to their 
position in the document. All elements should 
be deletable and editable in a form as source xml / xhtml.

c)
- It would be nice, when elements could be directly 
editable after their creation. (it enhances the 
working-speed with this form-editor enormously)
- eventually it would be nice to jump directly to this 
element with anchors... then it would eventually 
also make sense to give a short summary on the top 
of the page (i.e. of all the headlines) with anchors 
to the related parts on the page.

d)
- Align the buttons left.
Comment 1 mathias jud 2004-03-05 14:20:09 UTC
Jann Forrer wrote

> Problems:
> a)
> On long and element-rich sites, it is almost impossible
> to maintain the overview in the editor. Everything looks
> the same.

+1
I already tried some small modifications e.g. to differ the color of the
three rows which have different functionality (interface elements
edit/delete, node name,content).

> b)
> All Elements that actually can not be edited in the
> Form-Editor, are not shown there too.

And that together with a) make the orientation within the document
very difficult if you work in the form-editor.

>
[ ... ]
>
> b)
> - These non shown elements (Images / Assets ...) are very
> important for the orientation.
> - All content-elements should be shown relative to their
> position in the document. All elements should
> be deletable and editable in a form as source xml / xhtml.
>

I am not sure whether it is a good idea that all element have to be
deletable and editable but they ceratainly should be shown relativ to ther
position in the document which certailny would ease the orientation within
the document.

> c)
> - It would be nice, when elements could be directly
> editable after their creation. (it enhances the
> working-speed with this form-editor enormously)
> - eventually it would be nice to jump directly to this
> element with anchors... then it would eventually
> also make sense to give a short summary on the top
> of the page (i.e. of all the headlines) with anchors
> to the related parts on the page.
>
+1

Jann